MedTrucks – back to home
English
MedTrucks – back to home

Region

APL or ARS zoning: which indicator for your local healthcare assessment?

DREES’s APL and ARS zoning do not measure the same thing. How to interpret and combine them in a local health assessment for a CPTS or a DAC.

Anass El Hilal

·

·

6 min read

Aerial view of a rural village surrounded by vineyards

APL and ARS zoning address two different questions. APL, calculated by DREES, measures potential access to primary care on a municipality-by-municipality basis. Zoning, defined by each ARS, identifies areas eligible for practice installation incentives for physicians. A robust territorial assessment uses both, without conflating them.

This question arises whenever a CPTS drafts or updates its healthcare project, or when a DAC needs to explain to partners why an area is falling behind. The year 2026 brought both topics back into focus: on July 22, DREES published the 2024 APL values, and several ARS revised their physician zoning.

APL: A precise measure of healthcare access

The localized potential accessibility (APL) indicator was developed by DREES to measure, at a fine geographical level, the balance between the supply and demand for primary care. It is calculated for each municipality and broken down by profession: general practitioners, nurses, midwives, physiotherapists, and dental surgeons. The data is openly accessible on data.gouv.fr.

For general practitioners, APL is expressed as the number of accessible consultations per year per inhabitant. It combines practitioner proximity and availability. It weights healthcare supply against a standardized population, enabling comparisons between territories.

Three key benchmarks to keep in mind

  • 3.3 consultations per year per inhabitant: the average accessibility to general practitioners across France in 2024, according to DREES.

  • 2.5 consultations or fewer: the threshold below which a municipality is considered underserved in general practitioners in Insee publications.

  • A time lag: data published in July 2026 reflects the situation in 2024. Always specify the reference year used.

APL also has blind spots. It measures theoretical supply: it does not show whether practices are still accepting new patients. Nor does it capture the medico-social and social service landscape, which is essential for managing the complex patient pathways handled by DAC.

ARS zoning: A map to direct financial support

Physician zoning is a regulatory decision. Each ARS classifies territories within its region using a methodology established nationally by the decree of May 9, 2025. The geographical unit is not the municipality but the living-health area (territoire de vie-santé), as highlighted in the ARS Bretagne FAQ on the 2026 revision.

  • Priority Intervention Areas (ZIP) include territories facing the most severe doctor shortages. Installation incentives are highest here.

  • Complementary Action Areas (ZAC) are also eligible for financial support, though at a lower level.

  • Population caps govern the classification. The share of the regional population that can be classified as a ZIP ranges from 16.4% in Brittany to 71.3% in Centre-Val de Loire, according to ARS Bretagne.

New maps were released throughout the year. In Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes and Hauts-de-France, updated zoning took effect on January 1, 2026. In Nouvelle-Aquitaine, it was approved on January 30, 2026.

APL is one of the inputs used. However, zoning also reflects regional decisions: additional local criteria, consultations with healthcare professionals and elected officials, and compliance with population caps. This makes sense: its role is to prioritize financial support, not to provide a fine-grained measurement of healthcare access.

Why the two can seem contradictory

A municipality can show an APL above the 2.5 threshold yet still be designated a ZIP. The reverse is also true. Neither is an error. Three reasons usually explain this:

  1. Geographical scale: the municipality for APL, the living-health area for zoning. A well-served municipality may be part of an underserved wider territory.

  2. Timeframe: APL published in 2026 covers 2024, whereas zoning is enacted at a specific point in time and revised periodically.

  3. Purpose: one measures access, the other categorizes territories under population cap constraints.

In a territorial assessment, best practice is to cite both indicators with their source and date, and explain any divergence. This difference is often the most useful starting point for discussions with the ARS, CPAM, or local elected officials.

Building a solid territorial assessment

ARS guidelines require CPTS project leads to describe the population, the territory, and the care supply, and then share this analysis among stakeholders to set priorities. The framework provided in Hauts-de-France is a clear example. A few straightforward practices will strengthen your assessment:

  1. Start from the actual operational area. List the specific municipalities in the CPTS or DAC territory, rather than analyzing at the broader department level.

  2. Cross-reference multiple professions. General practitioner APL is not enough: review data for nurses and physiotherapists as well, published by DREES for the same years.

  3. Include the active zoning designation, along with the reference and date of the regional decree.

  4. Fill in what the numbers miss: medico-social and social organizations, up-to-date contact directories, and frontline feedback from local professionals.

  5. Date every data point. This ensures your assessment can be updated later without starting over from scratch.

Tools are available to get started. Rezone CPTS, for example, is an interactive mapping tool designed to support territorial assessments for healthcare projects; its data comes primarily from Assurance Maladie information systems (documentation published on the PAPS Normandie portal). If you lead a CPTS, our CPTS page details how a shared directory improves daily operations. For complex care coordination, visit our DAC page.

Inside MedVision, the territorial analysis module of MedMapping

In MedVision, GP accessibility (APL) is displayed on a map, municipality by municipality. Selecting a municipality shows its exact value and status.

MedVision, in MedMapping: General practitioner APL across the Var department, with Brignoles selected (APL of 3.1, under pressure status).

The indicator panel brings together the APL, population, and ARS zoning for the selected municipality. This provides the side-by-side analysis described above: two indicators next to each other, each serving its distinct purpose. In the Brignoles example, the APL is above the 2.5 threshold, yet the municipality is classified as a ZIP. This is precisely the kind of divergence a territorial assessment should explain.

MedVision, in MedMapping: APL, population, and ARS zoning for Brignoles, classified in a priority intervention area (ZIP).

The advantage lies in keeping the analysis and the directory on the same platform: once an area is identified, the team can immediately locate local professionals and organizations within MedMapping.

Summary

APL measures access; zoning allocates resources. The former quantifies healthcare access at a granular level, while the latter determines where financial incentives apply. Presenting both together, properly dated and sourced, eliminates common misunderstandings in steering committees.

Are you preparing or updating an assessment for your CPTS, DAC, or local authority? Learn more about our territorial assessment, or contact us to review your local data together.


What about your region?

Get a free assessment of healthcare services in your area within 48 hours, with no commitment.

Man using MedTrucks MedMapping (healthcare professional map) across two screens
Man using MedTrucks MedMapping (healthcare professional map) across two screens

They manage healthcare across their regions with MedTrucks

  • IESS (Innovation e-Santé Sud) logo
  • DAC Var Ouest Logo
  • e-Meuse santé footer logo
  • ARS PACA Logo
  • Pulsy logo
  • DAC 55 logo
MedTrucks

PariSanté Campus, 75015 Paris

contact@medtrucks.com

+33 (0) 6 13 91 52 68

MedTrucks on LinkedIn

Data hosted in France · GDPR compliant

© 2026 – MedTrucks – All rights reserved

PariSanté Campus
MedTrucks

PariSanté Campus, 75015 Paris

contact@medtrucks.com

+33 (0) 6 13 91 52 68

MedTrucks on LinkedIn

Data hosted in France · GDPR compliant

© 2026 – MedTrucks – All rights reserved

PariSanté Campus